Here’s one for ya: I didn’t actually love Love Actually the first time I saw it in the theater back in fall 2003. I thought it was unbelievably corny and hokey (and it is) and that it jumped around too much to ever get much traction with any of its plot lines or characters. I can’t recall exactly when or how a second viewing turned my head, but these days I love the movie for the corny and hokey, and it’s become one of my favorite rom-coms of all time.
(Another is About a Boy, which I also didn’t think was all that great on a first viewing and now adore. Maybe I’m just too cynical to let sappy romances sink in right away. Or I have a not-so-secret weakness for Hugh Grant.)
Point is, I fully understand why my co-redblogger James Rocchi and many other critics didn’t buy into everything Love Actually director Richard Curtis is selling in his newest film, Pirate Radio. By now, from James’ review and my interviews with director Curtis and star Tom Sturridge, you should know the basic premise of Pirate Radio (aka, The Boat that Rocked, its UK title): It’s Britain, 1966. Rock ‘n’ roll is barely played on the official BBC radio stations, so rock-minded entrepreneurs and true-believer DJs take to the North Sea to broadcast the music 24-7 from old converted freighters; even as the evil, uptight government plots to shut them down.
I’m easily seduced by the effective use of music in films, and the Pirate Radio soundtrack is stuffed full of excellent songs from the era. (All except the Beatles, thanks to licensing costs—but even that works in the film’s favor, allowing less-familiar gems to shine.) And the movie’s cast is a non-stop delight, from Bill Nighy doing his usual perfect lizard-like languor, through Philip Seymour Hoffman reprising his Lester Bangs routine from Almost Famous, to Rhys Ifans’ preening Jagger peacocking. The supporting tier of comic performances are also spot-on, including those of Nick Frost (Shaun of the Dead, Hot Fuzz), Chris O’Dowd, and Rhys Darby (Flight of the Conchords' moronic manager Murray).
Having seen it twice now, I’m fully aware of all of Pirate Radio’s obvious flaws: Its choppy, even lazy narrative structure full of contrivances; its reliance on the music to boost its energy and carry it along; its shallow misuse and abuse of its few female characters; its facile Us Vs. The Man politics; and of course Curtis’ deep love for grand, shameless, cornball gestures.
Curtis, who wrote Four Weddings and a Funeral, Notting Hill, and Bridget Jones’s Diary, is still learning the ropes as a director—and as much as he wanted Pirate Radio to play like MASH or Animal House, you can feel his heart isn’t really in the requisite scenes of silly hijinks and casual sex. (Even in Love Actually, when he tried to write a casual sex gag with Colin flying to Wisconsin to get laid, Curtis couldn’t help turning it back into a love connection.)
And yet, as James pointed out, if you go with all this and let the film’s glaring flaws wash away, Pirate Radio is exuberant, ecstatic fun. I could do that in this case, James couldn’t. I know exactly where he’s coming from: There are many, many supposed “feel-good” or “just-for-fun” movies where I just didn’t “feel” it or have “fun” and could not forgive them their failings. But frankly, I’m much more comfortable giving in, going with it, and letting blatantly manipulative charms smooth over weaknesses when the aimed-for end result is Curtis’s trademark brand of laughter and joy in service of his love for music—rather than, say, Hasbro’s cynical peddling of CGI cartoon violence and faux “honor” and “patriotism” in order to sell more Transformer or G.I. Joe toys.
I admit it, I’m ashamed at the guilty fun I had watching at least the first couple hours of 2012. Getting off on the spectacle of destruction and drawing glee from the death of millions is probably nothing you want to brag about. But I don’t apologize at all for loving Pirate Radio. It probably won’t end up on my Watch Every Year DVD shelf like Love Actually, but I’m already itching to see it again.
It’s cold, gray November in the Midwest, and having come off a month of nihilistic Halloween-y fright flicks, the theaters are now filling with smart-excellent-but-bummer films like Precious, The Road, and A Serious Man. So right about now, it’s nice to have Curtis’s huge-hearted film--with its unrelentingly giddy, chaotic love of rock--to take a bit of the chill off.
Recent Comments